Once upon a time, Miley Cyrus and her country music icon father Billy Ray Cyrus were seen as the perfect father-daughter pair. This perception was largely due to their on-screen relationship in the popular Disney show Hannah Montana,

The country star posted a birthday tribute to the fellow Grammy winner Nov. 23, the day she turned 32, amid a rumored family rift. Billy Ray shared throwback photos of the two, starting with pics of himself holding Miley when she was a baby and a toddler.

Billy Ray Cyrus shared a birthday tribute to his daughter Miley Cyrus, who turned 32 on Nov. 23, in an Instagram post filled with photos of the father-daughter duo over the years amid rumors of a Cyrus family rift.

It was rumored that Miley Cyrus and her father Billy Ray Cyrus were having issues but their recent comments show no proof of a feud between them

Miley’s mom, Tish Cyrus, also shared a post celebrating her daughter via Instagram. “Happy Birthday Little!!!” she captioned her Saturday post. “Cannot believe you turn 32 today…. Time has gone by so fast…. Love you so much ❤️@mileycyrus.”